Billy Graham was having doubts – in his ministry, in his rock-ribbed Christian faith, even in himself.
At age 30, he was president of a small Christian college in Minnesota. But he was better known as the skinny preacher with the booming voice who crisscrossed the country leading evangelistic crusades.
But the size and ardor of the crowds had begun to wane. After a “flop” in Altoona, Pennsylvania, Graham was almost ready to call it quits.
“It was sorriest crusade we ever had,” said his longtime friend and colleague Grady Wilson.
Even more troubling for Graham: A fellow preacher had been peppering him with questions about the trustworthiness of the Bible, hammering cracks in the bedrock of his faith.
Graham died on Wednesday at age 99. Presidents and pastors mourned his death, calling the evangelist one of this country’s most successful and beloved preachers.
But in August of 1949, Billy Graham was just another lost soul, looking for a little help from above.
Climbing the mountain
Handsome and charismatic, Charles Templeton was every bit the evangelist as Graham. The two friends traveled and preached together during the mid-1940s in the Youth For Christ movement.
More intellectually curious than Graham, Templeton had begun to read modern theology, which threw doubt on the historical accuracy of the Bible. He told Graham their faith was flimsy and urged him to study at a top seminary. The two evangelists wouldn’t be able to get by on their “animal magnetism and youthful enthusiasm” forever, Templeton argued.
Graham demurred, saying he “didn’t have a good enough mind” to settle deep theological questions. Templeton accused his friend of “intellectual suicide.”
Riled by the insult and wracked by doubts, Graham fled to Forest Home, a Christian retreat center tucked into Southern California’s San Bernardino Mountains. There, he wandered among the tall pines and wrestled with his misgivings.
Graham sat on a tree stump and opened his Bible on a big rock. He prayed and pondered, pleaded and struggled, until, finally, he surrendered, deciding to trust in the authority of the Bible, doubts be damned. (A bronze tablet marks the “Stone of Witness” at Forest Home.)
“He decided to simply preach the Gospel and not worry about the intellectual challenges of the faith,” said Randall Balmer, a professor of American religious history at Dartmouth University.
“He literally climbed down the mountain and never looked back.”
The Canvas Cathedral
His faith renewed, Graham poured everything into his next crusade, which began on September 25, 1949, in a Ringling Brothers-type tent pitched in downtown Los Angeles.
The tent stretched for a whole city block, and was rigged with seven poles, a large marquee bearing Graham’s intensely focused image, and a Bible propped open to Romans 12:2.
Postwar America simmered with spirituality and Bible sales were booming. Some scholars call the period the Third Great Awakening. Television had yet to steal the spotlight from other forms of entertainment, and Graham knew how to put on a good show.
“The crusades were meticulously planned,” said Balmer. “They made political conventions look like kindergarten.”
Graham persuaded organizers to spend $25,000 on billboards, radio spots and newspaper ads coaxing Californians to visit the “Canvas Cathedral” and hear “America’s Sensational Young Evangelist Preach.”
He preached with a passion that surprised even his longtime colleagues, according to William Martin’s biography, “A Prophet with Honor.”
He marched across the stage like a soldier, chopping the air with his arms, his long fingers pointing the ways to heaven or to hell, his Carolina tenor warning that the wages of sin is spiritual death.
In a subtle dig at Templeton, Graham said one night, “When God gets ready to shake America, he may not take the Ph.D. and the D.D. – God may choose a country boy. God may choose the man that no one knows, a little nobody, to shake America for Jesus Christ in this day, and I pray that he would!”
But turnout at the tent revival was disappointing: just 2,000-3,000 people per night, when more than 6,000 were expected. Chairs were spaced out to make the crowd look bigger.
Organizers “put out a fleece,” asking God to decide whether to continue the crusade, according to Martin’s biography.
If the weather warmed up, they would keep going. If not, they would shutter the Canvas Cathedral.
As it happened, a heat wave blew into Los Angeles, convincing the organizers to keep the crusade going.
But the hot spell was nothing compared to the media storm that would soon descend.
During the first few weeks of the Los Angeles crusade, a few B-list Hollywood celebrities lent their low-watt star power to the proceedings.
Stuart Hamblen, a “radio cowboy” who drank and gambled before Graham convinced him to stop backsliding, was an early convert, telling his radio audience he “heard the heavenly switchboard click” one night at the Canvas Cathedral.
But Hamblen’s epiphany couldn’t account for the horde of reporters and photographers who swarmed Graham as he walked into the tent one night in late October.
Graham grew alarmed, according to Martin, fearing the media frenzy were feeding on some unknown scandal in his ministry.
In fact, they had come to praise Graham, not to bury him.
“You have just been kissed by William Randolph Hearst,” one reporter told the young preacher, showing Graham a two-word telegram sent by the newspaper magnate to his ink-stained scribes. It said, simply, “Puff Graham.”
Within days, headlines in Hearst papers, the country’s largest chain, trumpeted the “new tide of faith” turning under the big tent in Los Angeles.
Newspapers across the country ran front-page stories about the conversions of Hamblen, Olympic runner Louis Zamperini and former mobster J. Arthur Vaus.
Other media soon joined the countrywide “amen corner.”
“Evangelist Graham seemed to be wielding the revival sickle as no one since Billy Sunday had wielded it,” raved Time magazine. Life magazine devoted four pages to the “rising young evangelist.”
Graham never fully understood why Hearst, engaged in a longtime extramarital affair and an even longer dalliance with dubious media ethics, decided to bestow his considerable blessing on the evangelist. The two men never met. And Hearst, famously reclusive, never gave an explanation.
Graham’s ardent anti-communism likely appealed to Hearst, but lots of preachers at the time warned of the Soviet threat, said Martin.
One thing is clear: The publicity campaign catapulted Graham into a new realm of fame.
“It was an enormous boost,” said Balmer, “if for no other reason than it gave credibility, which brought in money to the ministry.”
It also brought multitudes to the Canvas Cathedral. Attendance spiked to 6,000 a night, with hundreds more thronged outside the tent.
As organizers extended the crusade to accommodate the growing crowds, a sign hoisted on the marquee proclaimed, “Something’s Happening Inside, CONTINUING Another Week.”
But even Graham didn’t quite know what that “something” was.
“You better get back out here real fast,” he told a friend in Chicago, “because something has broken out that is way beyond me.”
In the crusade’s eighth “sin-smashing” week, Graham ran out of sermons and had to ask friends for suggestions. In an inspired bit of borrowing, one night he preached 18th century evangelist Jonathan Edward’s famous sermon, “Sinners in the Hand of an Angry God,” nearly word for word.
By the time the crusade ended on November 20, 1949, 350,000 people had heard Graham preach at the Canvas Cathedral and 3,000 had heeded the call to devote their lives to Christ, according to the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association. Untold millions read and heard about the crusade, making Graham a lifelong believer in the power of the press.
To commemorate the crusade, Graham’s association keeps a mural-sized photograph of the Canvas Cathedral at its headquarters in Charlotte, North Carolina.
“They regard that crusade as the changing of the water into wine,” said Martin.
It’s hard to overstate the effects of the crusade – and its media coverage – on Graham’s ministry.
“I don’t think there’s any question that it’s what thrust him into the national consciousness,” said Martin.
Consider the following example: In 1948, the year before the Los Angeles crusade, 65,000 people came to hear Graham preach. In 1950, that number rose to 1.8 million, and continued to crest for decades.
As for Charles Templeton, unlike his friend, he attended Princeton Theological Seminary.
He later left the ministry and gained prominence as a journalist in Canada. But he lost his Christian faith, saying he couldn’t believe the Bible anymore.
He died an agnostic.
The article you shared delves into the intriguing story of Billy Graham, a renowned evangelist whose faith was tested and ultimately reaffirmed in the face of doubt and challenges. My expertise lies in religious history, particularly in the lives of influential figures like Graham and the context surrounding their work.
Billy Graham, widely celebrated for his evangelistic crusades, faced a critical period in his faith journey during the late 1940s. The article highlights Graham's moment of doubt spurred by his colleague Charles Templeton's intellectual questioning of the Bible's historical accuracy. This encounter pushed Graham to retreat to Forest Home in California, where he grappled with his uncertainties, ultimately reaffirming his faith in the authority of the Bible.
The Canvas Cathedral in downtown Los Angeles serves as a pivotal backdrop for Graham's resurgence. Despite initial low turnout, a media storm ignited by William Randolph Hearst's endorsement propelled Graham to national fame. The fervor surrounding the crusade led to a significant increase in attendees and media coverage, marking a turning point in Graham's ministry.
Notably, Graham's steadfast commitment to preaching the Gospel, despite doubts and challenges, defined his legacy. His ability to connect with audiences, coupled with meticulous planning and a passionate delivery, contributed to the success of his crusades and the enduring impact on religious landscapes.
Charles Templeton, Graham's contemporary and once close friend, pursued theological studies but eventually left the ministry, renouncing his Christian faith and passing away as an agnostic.
The narrative surrounding Billy Graham's journey of faith and his resilience in the face of doubt is a compelling testament to the complexities and challenges inherent in religious leadership and belief systems.